Freud e il non europeo

اولین مواجهه من با اثری از ادوارد سعید از قضا مواجهه ای روانکاوانه بود، در ادامه‌ی مطالعات روانکاوی که چند سالی است درگیر آنم. پس از خواندن توتم و تابو فروید، ذهنم درگیر سوال از روان دیگر اقوام بدوی که در اثر اشاره ای به آنها نشده، بود. سعید در این اثر دست به تحلیل کتاب توتم و تابو در راستای مسأله ی Leggi tutto

The point of Said's lecture is that Freud's appropriation(s) of his own identity, as exemplified primarily in his last book, 'Moses and Monotheism', points out ways in which the Palestine/Israel conflict might be constructively handled. For those unfamiliar with the text, Freud assumes monotheism to Leggi tutto

پیشنهادم اینه که پیش از خوانش کتاب، موسی و یکتاپرستی فروید رو مطالعه کنید و اشراف کلی‌ای هم بر اتفاقات تاریخی فلسطین و اسرائیل داشته باشید. گرچه اولی رو اگر نخونده باشید باز هم نقد و تبیین ادوارد سعید شفاف و روشن باقی می‌مونه اما دومی رو به نظرم اگر هیچ چیزی ازش ندونید کمی ساختار استدلال‌های این سخن Leggi tutto

I read Said's Orientalism a couple of years back and was totally blown away. As it was relatively short, I decided to pick up this essay during a lunch break at work. In typical Said fashion he references countless literary, historical and political sources. At its core, Said set about critiquing

Very important text to understand the phenomena of identity in the present day context—of Palestine and Israel. Edward Said clearly states that though there are so many conflicting accounts regarding Freud's understanding of his Jewish identity and racial history, Freud was confident enough when he Leggi tutto

Etkileyici bir konuşmanın kitaplaştırılmış hali idi. Edward Said zaten sosyal bilimlerle uğraşan herkesin hakkında şöyle ya da böyle bilgi sahibi olduğu bir entelektüel. Her ne kadar daha çok şarkiyatçılık konseptiyle tanınsa da psikoloji ve edebiyat üzerine ne kadar bilgi sahibi olduğunu gördüm bu Leggi tutto

There is a deadly dose of anti-semitism covered within an intellectual / academic debate. The book could have been a perfect 5-star if Said wasn't so bluntly biased and preacher for anti-israeli/zionism agenda to prove. There is a lot to learn from the book, nonetheless, about Freud and his very contr Leggi tutto

Said and Rose be cooking fr fr fr

A brilliant reading of Freud's Moses and Monotheism by the late Edward Said. It originates as a talk given at the Freud Museum in London. After Said's talk, Jacqueline Rose responded, and her response was fittingly included in the Verso book. Said concludes: "Freud's uneasy relationship with the ortho Leggi tutto